They all take place in different locations. The set pieces in Girls Trip go somewhere, literally. The Girls Trip women have it the Rough Night women don't.Ĭomedies like this place a lot of stock in their set pieces, and here I noticed a big distinction as well. But chemistry is the biggest factor here. Girls Trip also has this scene, and I suppose in a sense, they are more "like" each other in that they are all black women. Perhaps because Rough Night needs to offer us an array of demographic types, including a heavier one, a lesbian one (who also functions as Jewish one) and a black one, it convinces us a little less that they were all friends in college, despite a scene showing them in those days. They do in Girls Trip and they don't in Rough Night - though I suppose I should acknowledge that Rough Night has the responsibility to be all things to all people, while Girls Trip can exist as more of a niche product intended for African-American audiences (and anyone else who happens to want to watch). The big difference is how much these four feel like they were actually friends in college. A fifth outsider is added in both cases as well, though she plays more of a role in Rough Night than Girls Trip. My own numerical grade, had I been reviewing it, would have been 50% of what I gave Girls Trip, or 4/10.īoth films feature a core group of four college friends who get back together for a wild weekend that celebrates their previous wild times, and as might be expected, they have differing personalities with all personality types represented - the uptight one, the crazy one, etc. Rough Night, it turns out, deserved to make only 20% of what Girls Trip made. Any time a Girls Trip comes along, I am relieved to be reminded that I'm still making good on that implicit oath. You're supposed to divorce yourself from your particular biases and see the films through the eyes of the person it was meant for. In fact, a friend who saw Girls Trip and thought my 8/10 review here was generous said "I don't think I was the target audience." Well, as a critic, you are always the target audience. As I am a white male about to turn 44, there are certain films that are more likely to be aimed at me than others, and your average person tends to gravitate more toward films aimed at them. box office - which is $80 million more than Rough Night made.įor me personally, though, it helps reinforce my critic's oath to remove my own personal demographics as much as possible from my judgment of a film.
#Bridget everett put your dick away movie
In that regard I'm glad to say the movie seems to have been a smashing success, bypassing $100 million at the U.S. Box office is probably the better way to determine how well a movie is legitimately liked, and in the case of a movie like Girls Trip, probably the only way, as awards talk won't enter into it.
For one, especially in the post-"Oscars so white" era, I want primarily black films to be genuinely appreciated by people, and not just included in awards discussions for reasons of liberal do-gooder tokenism. This is for a couple reasons, some societal and some specific to me. I don't want to go around artificially inflating the value of movies made by and starring African-Americans, though I do breathe a sigh of relief whenever I genuinely love one. None of these things were true for Rough Night, which I saw last night. I thought the tone was great, the set pieces were suitably hilarious (if not all totally successful), and the friendship between the characters seemed real. When I saw Girls Trip three weeks ago, though, my fears of its inferiority - not with respect to Rough Night, which I hadn't seen yet, but in general - were immediately laid to rest. Just because the distinction was problematic, though, didn't make it not true, and I worried a bit about that going into them. Well, twice at least, on two different podcasts.Īlthough the podcasters deemed both films to have a bit of value, it seemed pretty clear that Rough Night was considered the mildly superior effort - a problematic distinction since Girls Trip has a cast of primarily African-Americans (with one notable exception), while Rough Night has a cast of primarily whites (with one not-so-notable exception).
Before I had seen either of them, I heard Rough Night and Girls Trip being compared to one another quite a bit.
0 kommentar(er)
